Whether you prefer PC or console gaming, being able to communicate in a multiplayer game is super handy, which is why many of us invest in a quality headset or microphone to ensure we sound clear to our teammates. But you only need one of these audio devices, so which should you choose?
It's not a totally clear-cut decision. Your choice will likely depend on what type of game you most frequently play, whether you need the same audio device for calls outside of gaming, and even what platform you use to play your games.
Console players will most likely want something comfortable and convenient so that when you're focused on a multiplayer game on your PS5 or Xbox, you don't need to worry about where you need to direct your voice. A console headset is always a safe bet, but you may still want to opt for a proper microphone. The same goes for PC gaming audio gear, but since you'll be closer to the screen and often at a desk, the battle between mic and headset is much closer.
We're here to help make the choice a bit easier for you. We've had a look at the key factors you'll want to consider and then summarised which of the two we think is best for PC and console gaming.
What factors to consider?
When it comes to choosing between a headset or a microphone, it's best to weigh up their strengths and weaknesses.
For a headset, you've got a design that follows your head. All you need to do is pull down the mic itself, and you can trust that your words will reach it without bother. Anyone with a microphone and a swivel chair knows the pain of accidentally moving too far away when talking and becoming inaudible, so it's definitely a plus to be able to avoid that.
Headsets also tend to be quite convenient. Many of them have audio controls attached near the top third of the cable, allowing you to adjust your volume or even mute yourself at a moment's notice. Having the controls always in reach is really handy. The even more apparent benefit of a headset design is that it doubles as headphones. That means one less port and connection to worry about, and having your core audio devices all in one package.
In most cases, a decent headset is noticeably more affordable than a decent microphone.
As for stand-alone microphones, the clear benefit is the audio quality. A headset can sound good, but many of them can be a bit tinny and so-so, whereas a microphone has no trouble sounding great. Sure, they are usually quite a bit more expensive, but it's worth it for sounding so good. This also makes them a great pick for those working from home or who need to record audio outside as gaming, as they are much better for these tasks than a simple headset.
A microphone will usually need to USB port, so you might be a bit restricted by that. What isn't restricted is the design itself. Unlike a headset, you're not tethered to a pair of over-ear headphones, and can instead use earbuds, external speakers, or any other type of audio output. The cups of a headset often get quite stuffy when wearing them for a long session, so the freedom of choice (and freedom for ears) of a microphone is definitely a plus factor.
Which is best for PC gaming?
While a headset is still a good choice for PC gaming, especially if you're on a budget, we think choosing a microphone is the best pick here. The additional versatility is super handy, especially if you already need good audio quality for work and/or social voice calls.
Although the price tag for a decent quality microphone is a bit of a stinger, they tend to last much longer than a regular headset, so it's an investment that won't be that much more costly in the long run.
The main drawback is the need for an additional USB port. It shouldn't be too much trouble if you have a PC tower, but those using a laptop probably already ran out of them just from needing a separate keyboard and mouse. Luckily, in such a case, you can use a USB splitter/hub.
We especially like a headset for PC gaming as it means we're not completely tethered by a wire, although you will want to make sure to speak into it and not face away by accident.
Which is best for console gaming?
In contrast to PC gaming, we actually recommend opting for a headset for console gaming. Chances are you're not tied to a desk when using your console, so the added convenience of not having to think about where to put a microphone can't be understated. It's a lot easier to relax on a couch and play games when using a headset.
Since your hands will be on your controller most of the time, being able to quickly adjust the audio controls without a break in action is also a big plus. You won't need to worry about volume output either, as since headsets are also headphones, things should be a lot less noisy for your other housemates. Just be sure to keep an ear out for your own volume.
You can still make a stand-alone microphone work, and if you already own one it's definitely worth trying out before you decide to purchase a headset, but we think it's the inferior choice in most cases for console gaming.
Kyle Purves is a Tech Product Writer for What’s The Best, with an avid interest in all things gaming and tech.
Subscribe to the What’s The Best Newsletter to keep up to date with more of the latest reviews and recommendations from the rest of the What’s The Best team.