The best sandwich toasters

Now that lots of us are still working from home, so invest in a sandwich toaster for the ultimate lunchtime treat.

Best sandwich makers

by Lily Anderson |
Updated on

The way we work has changed forever, and for a lot of us, that means that setting up a makeshift office on our kitchen table is normal. We're pretty used to it now. One benefit of working from home is that we have more time to prepare lunch. Whether you’re looking for a healthy snack or something more challenging like making pasta, we’re trying it all.

Making a tasty treat doesn’t have to take the whole of your lunch hour, especially when you invest in one of the best sandwich toasters. These will allow you to create the perfect panini or toastie from your own kitchen with minimal effort.

Related: The best waffle makers

We've rounded up the best-rated sandwich toasters on the web, as well as some of our experts have tested themselves. Great lunches await you!

Gallery

The best sandwich makers

George Foreman 25800 Small Fit Grill1 of 6

George Foreman 25800 Small Fit Grill

This little appliance is great for houses without loads of counter space, as it tucks away neatly into a cupboard. It's easy to use and comes with a drip tray to catch any rogue cheese or fat. You can cook more than just toasties in it, so it's a brilliant multi-use tool.Key specifications:760W25.6 x 19.3 x 7.7cmVertical storage with cord wrapSpeedy heat upNon-stick coatingTried and tested, 2020, Jade Moscrop, Commercial Content Writer:"If it's just one sandwich or panini you're making, this grill is the ideal size. It heats up super quickly so there's no waiting around and is really easy to clean with a cloth afterwards. I find that I need to put something on top of the lid to really get that sealed in perfect toastie (my choice is a large tub of peanut butter), but it cooks evenly. The lid gets quite hot, so don't attempt to push it down yourself. For the price, I can't complain."

Breville VST057 2 Portion Sandwich Toaster2 of 6
CREDIT: Argos

Breville VST057 2 Portion Sandwich Toaster

Do you have some left-over baguette from a BBQ? Transform the carby goodness into a panini. This will save you a trip to the supermarket on your lunch.Key specifications: 1080WHandle locking clipNon-stickReheat functionCord storageManufacturer's one-year guarantee

NoStik Toastie Toaster Sleeves3 of 6
CREDIT: John Lewis & Partners

NoStik Toastie Toaster Sleeves

Are you looking for a cheap way to update your sandwich? The NoStik Toastie Toaster Sleeves from John Lewis & Partners transforms an ordinary ham and cheese sandwich and takes it to another level. Key specifications: Set of twoH17 x W14cmDishwasher safeSafe to 260°CDon't use with sharp utensils

Tower Mini Panini Press Grill4 of 6

Tower Mini Panini Press Grill

Do you live at home alone or just with your partner? A mini panini grill is a handy kitchen tool, which will help you create tasty snacks quickly. Sandwiches aren't the only thing you can make with this machine, try grilling off some vegetables to accompany your dinner. Key specifications: Automatic temperature control28.8 x 24.6 x 11.2 cm700WOne-year guarantee or get extended two-year warranty upon registration.

George Foreman Large Red Steel Grill5 of 6

George Foreman Large Red Steel Grill

Everybody should own at least one handy kitchen appliance that does almost anything, and that's exactly what a George Foreman grill does. Create everything from delicious waffles to mouthwatering burgers and sausages. Key specifications: Easy to clean37.1 x 37.9 x 10.7 cmReady to cook indicator lightsTwo-year guarantee, plus one-year when you register it online

Salter EK3677 Handbag Style Toastie Maker6 of 6

Salter EK3677 Handbag Style Toastie Maker

So, if you think that your average ham and cheese sarnie needs an upgrade, why not spice it up with a Salter Handbag Toaster? It comes in super handy...**Key Specifications:**Stylish Design‎27.5 x 26.1 x 12 cmCompact and easy to storeReady to cook indicator lights

Figured out which toastie maker you want to buy? Perfect. Now, let's talk cooking inspiration.

So you don't spend your whole lunch hour Googling what to make, we've found a magnificent sandwich toaster recipe for you to follow. You're welcome!

Our favourite sandwich toaster recipe

The Reuben sandwich

Ingredients needed

Dressing:

One tbsp of mayonnaise

One tbsp of tomato ketchup

One tsp of horseradish sauce

A dash of hot sauce

A dash of Worcestershire sauce

One tsp of finely chopped shallots

Two cornichon or half a dill pickle, finely chopped

A pinch of of hot paprika

Sandwich:

Two slices of light rye bread or sourdough

Two/three slices of salt beef

A few slices of Swiss cheese, such as emmental or gruyère

Two/three tbsp of sauerkraut

Pinch of salt and freshly ground black pepper

Dill pickles to serve with

Instructions

  1. Mix together all the dressing ingredients in a bowl, then season with salt and pepper.
  1. Make sure to butter both sides of your bread then place the dressing and other ingredients inside.
  1. Heat your sandwich maker and place the sandwich inside. Leave to cook for three to four minutes and then serve with dill pickles.

Recipe from the BBC

Toasted sandwich
©Photo: Unsplash

How to use a sandwich maker

Every sandwich toaster is different, so the best way to use your sandwich maker will be to check the instructions provided. Follow each step, to begin with, and with a little experimentation, you'll figure out all the tips and tricks to get the perfect toasted sandwich.

Top tip: butter both sides of the bread to make your sandwich extra crispy.

Can you wash a sandwich toaster?

You will need to wash the plates of the sandwich maker after every use to keep it in tip-top condition and to stop it from becoming grimy and gross. Before you start to clean, make sure you turn it off and unplug it from the mains. Only begin cleaning once the machine is completely cool.

Once cool, you'll be able to clean the sandwich maker with warm soapy water. Some sandwich toasters will have removable plates that may be dishwasher safe - always check the instructions before attempting to clean.

Can sandwich makers create waffles?

Yes indeed, some sandwich makers can make waffles. However, these sandwich makers will need to use a waffle plate. If you can't get a waffle plate for your brand, then you won't be able to make them, unfortunately.

What to read next:

The best soup makers to add to your kitchen

Boiled, poached and scrambled: Here's how to cook your favourite eggs

The best toasters to give you the perfect crunch

Are you a Prime member?

Have you signed up for Amazon Prime yet? You can sign up today for a free 30-day trial and find out what all the fuss is about. You get free next-day delivery on thousands of items, plus so much more – Prime Video, Prime Reading, Amazon Family, and more.

Lily Anderson is a writer at Bauer Media, where she tests products for titles such as Heat, Closer, What’s The Best and Mother&Baby.

Subscribe to the What’s The Best Newsletter to keep up to date with more of the latest reviews and recommendations from Lily and the rest of the What’s The Best team.

Just so you know, whilst we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website, we never allow this to influence product selections - read why you should trust us